In Neo Essel Dispoware Pvt. Ltd. v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., decided by the NCDRC, a plastics manufacturer lost about $443,000 in a factory fire. The loss was assessed by the insurer’s own surveyor. The policy covered fire. The insurer had accepted the full premium. The claim was still rejected.
The reason was timing. The policy began on 17 October 2016. Instead of paying the premium of about $30,000 upfront, the company gave a bank guarantee, as it had in earlier years, when the insurer allowed it up to 120 days to pay. The fire broke out twelve days later, on 29 October. The premium was paid in January 2017.
The law does not allow that much credit. Under Section 64VB of the Insurance Act and Rule 58, when cover starts before the premium is received, the premium must be paid by the end of the following month. Here, that meant 30 November 2016. The NCDRC held that this deadline is fixed by statute. It cannot be extended by private arrangement, and the insurer cannot waive it, however long the practice has gone on.
The insurer did not escape entirely. The Commission found that Oriental had misled the company by accepting a late premium without explaining the consequences. Worse, after learning of the fire, it never told the company that paying by 30 November would still have kept the cover alive. Oriental was ordered to refund the premium of about $30,000 with 12% interest and pay about $45,500 in compensation.
Note: $ stands for USD and conversion used is $1 = INR 94.6
A shopping mall in Johannesburg. A lockdown claim worth more than $60 million. Five insurers who said the cover was never meant to be there. And a court that told them: you signed it.
In AIG South Africa Ltd v Azrapart (Pty) Ltd, the owners of Fourways Mall took out an all-risk policy with business interruption cover, placed through Marsh with five insurers led by AIG, which carried 70% of the risk. Cover began on 1 December 2019.
During the negotiations, quotes went back and forth across about ten versions. Infectious and contagious disease cover appeared in some and disappeared from others, and no one flagged the changes. The final placing slip, signed by the insurers, included the disease cover. So did the final policy, which AIG’s underwriter signed in March 2020.
Weeks later, South Africa went into COVID-19 lockdown. The mall’s owners claimed more than $60 million in lost rental income.
The insurers argued that an earlier quote from November 2019, which left out disease cover, was the real contract, and asked the court to correct the policy as a drafting mistake. The High Court in Johannesburg rejected this in 2024. The signed policy was the contract, and earlier negotiation documents could not be used to contradict it. The underwriter who signed it was never called to give evidence.
Four of the insurers settled on the eve of the appeal. The fifth, Insurance Underwriting Managers, carried on. On 14 November 2025, South Africa’s Supreme Court of Appeal dismissed its appeal with costs. To rewrite a signed contract, an insurer must clearly prove that both sides intended something different from what the document says. IUM called no witnesses, and only raised the alleged mistake in 2022, after the claim had arrived. The exclusion had never been highlighted, and the rule the parties worked under was that anything not highlighted would be taken as accepted.
The insurers who wrote the policy were held to its words.
Note: $ stands for USD and conversion used is $1 = ZAR 16.6
5.1%
India’s general insurance premiums are forecast to grow by just 5.1% in 2026, according to GlobalData, down from an estimated 8.5% in 2025. GlobalData expects growth to recover from 2027, taking the market from US$43.4 billion in 2026 to US$62.2 billion by 2030.